DIY fajita seasoning or taco seasoning; such a seemingly simple question! However, it can be a bit of a predicament if you are halfway through cooking your chicken when you realise you have no fajita seasonings to hand. You have used up the last of your packet and your recipe specifically calls for fajita. Do you freak out? No! They are quite similar and just a few changes will make up the difference. Everyone has had this happen to them at some point.
In this post I will show you what is different about the two seasonings. I will give you an easy recipe for both using spices you probably already have. I will also show you when they can be substituted for each other, how much to use per pound and how to make a large batch of one seasoning which can be used for both. No need to buy packets of seasoning, they are full of unnecessary salt!
DIY Fajita Seasoning vs Taco Seasoning: The Key Differences
Fajita seasoning can be seen as a close relative to taco seasoning. They share many similarities, including being based on chili powder, cumin, garlic powder and paprika. However, taco seasoning will generally have a more earthy and spicy flavour; this is perfect for using on ground meat. Fajita seasoning will be a bit more zingy and smoky to compliment the quick searing of the chicken/steak and veggie strips.
Generally the difference between the two comes down to some added ingredients. Taco seasonings will often have a small amount of corn starch added to help thicken up the sauce. Fajitas rarely have this addition and often include some citrus additions such as lime zest or lime powder. As brands will differ, this is just a general trend. You can easily create your own jar of seasoning to suit your preference.
What’s Inside Taco Seasoning vs Fajita Seasoning

Before putting any together, it is best to have a look at exactly what goes into each jar. Although most of the spices are repeated between the two blends, the ingredient list is short. However, the proportions are different and there are a few additions. We will take a look at what goes into each blend and what each spice does. Once you know how they work together you will find it much easier to adapt your batches.
Taco Seasoning Ingredients and What Each One Does
Chili powder is the base of this taco seasoning. It gives a hint of spice and color. Cumin provides the earthy, warm flavor that most associate with tacos. Paprika provides a touch of sweetness. Garlic powder and onion powder add some savory flavor. Oregano adds some light herb flavor. Finally, salt and pepper. You can also add some corn starch to thicken if you like.
Fajita Seasoning Ingredients and What Each One Does
The main ingredients remain the same, but they are used differently. More paprika is used, often smoked, to give that grilling flavor. Chili powder and cumin are still used. However many people reduce the amount of cumin. Lime zest or lime powder is also used to give that fresh fajita taste. Cayenne pepper is used to give some extra heat and a small amount of brown sugar helps the meat caramelise.
How to Make DIY Taco Seasoning

Place your small bowl and fork into the counter. Using your measuring tools, add 1 tablepoon of the chilli powder, then add a teaspoon of cummin, paprika, garlic powder and onion powder. Stir in 1/2 tsp dried oregano, 1/2 tsp salt and 1/4 tsp black pepper. Mix well to make an even colour. You should have around 3 tablespoons of mixture. Takes 2 mins.
Top Tip: Use fresh smelling spices. Old cumin will taste very dusty and there is no way of getting rid of it in any recipe. If you want a thicker sauce on your meat, add a teaspoon of cornstarch. For more heat add 1/4 tsp of cayenne. As you are controlling how much salt goes in, you can halve the amount without losing too much flavour.
How to Make DIY Fajita Seasoning
Add 1 tablespoon of smoked paprika, 2 teaspoons of chilli powder, 1 teaspoon of cumin, 1 teaspoon of garlic powder, 1 teaspoon of onion powder. Then mix together 1/2 teaspoon of brown sugar, 1/4 teaspoon of cayenne, 1/2 teaspoon of salt and 1/4 teaspoon of black pepper. This will make around 3 tablespoons. The smoked paprika will give your fajita blend some lovely grilled notes.
The lime really gives your fajitas some zing! I find dried lime zest can be difficult to find in most stores so it’s easier just to juice some fresh lime over the pan after you’ve cooked the meat. Add the spice mix before searing the meat and turn the heat up to high to get some nice colour on the meat from the sugar.
Can You Swap Taco Seasoning for Fajita Seasoning?

Yes! These two seasonings are very similar to each other so you can swap them without anything going wrong with your meal. The difference between them is that taco seasoning will give your fajita strips more of an earthy taste but also a bit less flavour. Fajita seasoning with give your ground beef more of a smoked and lighter flavour. Just use the same quantity as the recipe says.
Make a few small adjustments when using taco seasoning in place of fajita seasoning. Add a pinch of smoked paprika and some fresh lime juice to the top of your pan. If using fajita seasoning in place of taco meat, add an extra 1/2 tsp of cumin and a little chili powder. You could also add a splash of water to make it more saucy. Just taste your meal before serving as a small adjustment can turn your meal from a bland one to something tasty!
How Much Seasoning to Use for Each Dish
The quantity can vary depending on how much you’re cutting and how you cook it. However, a good starting point is a little under one batch of either of these recipes. This would be around two tablespoons of your mix per pound of meat. Once cooked, taste and if you want a more intense flavour next time simply add a little more. Always season your dry meat as any extra moisture will cause the spices to wash off.
Taco Meat Amounts Per Pound
Add 2 tablespoons taco seasoning mix to your ground beef, turkey or chicken. Brown meat and drain off excess fats. Stir the seasoning mix into the meat along with 1/3 cup water and cook on low heat for 5-8 minutes until the liquid reduces and has thickened. If you added a cornstarch blend then it will stick to your meat quicker. Use slightly less water for the crunchy shells and a little more for the soft shell tacos or burrito bowls.
Fajita Strips Amounts Per Pound
Season the fajita strips with about 2 tablespoons of fajita spice mix per pound of sliced Chicken/Steak. Mix with 1 tablespoon of oil and cook in batches on high heat so it chars instead of boils. Towards the end add the sliced peppers and onions and season again with a little more spice mix. Finish off with some lime juice.
Make One Bulk Base for Both Blends
Make a large batch so you don’t have to combine two jars. Whisk together the chili powder (1/4 cup), cumin, garlic and onion powders (4 tsp each), the salt (2 tsp) and black pepper (1 tsp). Whisk until evenly combined and you should have 9 tablespoons. This will make enough to season 4 meals with some leftover.
For your meal, use 2 tablespoons per pound of meat. If making tacos, mix in the dried oregano (1/2 tsp), paprika (1 tsp) and if making fajitas mix in smoked paprika (1 tsp), brown sugar (1/2 tsp) and cayenne (1/4 tsp). Mix these into your portion of the seasoning rather than the jar so you can still keep it pliable for either recipe.
Storing Homemade Taco and Fajita Seasoning

Spices will start to lose their flavour so choose airtight glass containers with screw on lids. Store in a cool dark cabinet away from the stove. Be sure to label your jars with the mix name and date you made it. Use a small funnel to make filling easy and avoid getting any of the spice on your worktop.
When making your own spice mixes they are at their best around 6 months after being made. This means you should be able to use any large batches in plenty of time. After this point they will start to lose their flavour gradually. If any jars smell old then throw them away. Keep a small jar of your mix handy on your stove and just top it up from the large jar. This will mean your main jar remains sealed. Never shake spices directly over a hot pan as this will cause the jar to get clumpy due to the moisture.
FAQs on DIY Fajita Seasoning vs Taco Seasoning
Is fajita seasoning the same as taco seasoning?
Not really. They are very similar because both taco and fajita seasoning contain chili powder, cumin, garlic and paprika. Taco seasoning tends to be more of an earthy blend and will usually contain some corn. Fajita seasoning is more smoky and zesty. Because there are a lot of similar ingredients they can be used interchangeably. Just add a bit of paprika, cumin, or lime to taste.
Can I use taco seasoning on fajitas?
Yes! To make this recipe, simply use the same amount of seasoning you would for fajita seasoning. If you’re using sliced chicken or steak, you should use 2 tablespoons per pound. Add a dash of smoked paprika and a squeeze of lime juice at the end. Don’t use any cornflour based recipes as you wouldn’t want your fajitas to be a thick sauce.
Which is spicier in DIY fajita seasoning vs taco seasoning?
By default, the fajita mix in this post will be slightly spicier due to the 1/4 tsp of cayenne pepper added. However, the taco mix contains an optional amount of cayenne. As you are making this yourself, you can add extra cayenne pepper to make it spicy or none at all for the kids!
How much homemade seasoning equals one store packet?
The usual quantity contained in a packet is enough for seasoning one pound of meat. Use around 2 tablespoons of your home-made seasoning mixture per pound of meat. Different brands can have different quantities in their packets so be sure to check how much there is in yours. Once you have used this quantity try tasting the dish and next time alter the quantity to suit your family’s taste.
How long does homemade taco or fajita seasoning last?
The two blends are at their best after being stored in an airtight glass jar in a cool dark cupboard for around 6 months. They will normally last longer than this but will gradually lose their flavour. Be sure to label your jars with the date they were made, and if they smell stale when opening the jar, throw them away.
How do I make either blend low sodium?
Halve the amount of salt used or omit altogether and season the dish at the table. You’ll still get lots of flavour from the smoked paprika, cumin and lime juice. The ready-made seasoning can be quite salty so by making your own you know exactly how much salt you’re using in each batch.
Final Thoughts on DIY Fajita Seasoning vs Taco Seasoning
The key thing to note is that these two seasonings are closely related. You can use the same pantries for both. The taco seasoning has more of an earthy taste whilst the fajita has more of a smokey and bright taste. With a few minor adjustments you can make them interchangeable. You also get to control how salty and spicy they are.
Give it a go! Make up a large batch this weekend and then grab the amount you need when you’re making tacos. Don’t forget to adjust to suit your family. Leave me a comment and let me know which one you enjoyed the most.