Creating the perfect everything bagel seasoning blend can be tricky. Often store bought ones can be too salty or just filled with plain sesame seeds. However, with a bit of knowledge on how much of each ingredient to add you can create your own. If you get it wrong though, you will have a boring and salty seasoning that will overpower your avocado toast.
In this post I am going to show you a simple ratio to make your own everything bagel seasoning blend. I will show you what ingredients go into it and how to mix them up in around 5 minutes. I will also show you how to reduce the sodium content. There are some simple swaps you can do to save you from a bad tasting seasoning. I have included some storage tips too. Get a small bowl and some pantry items and you will have this sorted in no time!
What’s in DIY Everything Bagel Seasoning?

There are 5 key ingredients needed to create every great everything bagel mixture. Sesame seeds will give your bagels a nutty crunch whilst poppy seeds give a slightly earthy kick. You’ll need dried minced garlic and onion to give your bagels that savoury taste. Finally, add some coarsely ground salt to bind everything together. You’ll have everything you need to get started if you already have these in your cupboard!
Quality is really important when making your everything bagel seasoning. It’s much better to use toasted sesame seeds rather than raw. Either buy pre-toasted or toast in a dry pan for a few minutes. Use flaky sea salt or kosher salt. This will keep the salt crunchy as they have larger salt crystals. However fine table salt will give you more salt per spoonful so use less.
The Everything Bagel Seasoning Ratio DIY Formula
Most recipes will ask you to measure out ingredients in tablespoons. Whilst this is fine to make one jar, if you want to make more or less than one jar, you can run into issues. Using ratios will solve this problem. A part can be any size spoon or scoop you use. As long as you use the same size of spoon or scoop for each ingredient, you will have mastered the ratio for making your own everything bagel seasoning.
My Go-To Everything Bagel Seasoning Ratio

In a bowl mix together 2 parts sesame seeds, 1 part poppy seeds, 1 part dried minced garlic, 1 part dried minced onion and 1 part coarse salt. Using a mixture of white and black sesame seeds will give the traditional speckled appearance. If you use one tablespoon as a guide you’ll have six tablespoons, which should fit in a small jar. Check the seasoning by tasting a pinch on a cracker.
How to Scale the Blend Up or Down
This recipe works well with scaling. For a small test batch add 1/2 a tsp for your portion of the recipe to make around 1 tablespoon. For a gift size jar increase to 1/4 cup to make around 1 1/2 cups. The ratio will be the same meaning the taste will be consistent. You should only use one measuring tool and ensure you are filling the measure level.
Why the Salt Ratio Matters
The salt is where people often go wrong. If you overdo it, it will be quite bitter. If you under do it, the mix won’t come alive on the bagel. A good place to start is 1/6th, but really it depends on your taste. As you will be putting this on a salty item such as cream cheese, you may find that less is better, however, it’s easy to add extra at the table.
How to Make DIY Everything Bagel Seasoning in 5 Minutes

Toast the sesame seeds. Place a dry pan over medium low. Add the sesame seeds and cook stirring constantly for 2-3 minutes. You will know they are done when they are fragrant and lightly golden. Transfer to a plate immediately so they stop cooking, as they will continue to cook in the hot pan. Leave to fully cool before mixing up so that any condensation doesn’t cause your mixture to clump together.
Place all ingredients in a small bowl or clean jar. Mix together using a spoon. 2 parts sesame seeds, 1 part poppy seeds, 1 part garlic, 1 part onion, 1 part salt. If you prefer you can screw the lid on and shake for around 30 seconds. Taste a little and adjust salt and garlic if needed. Once the seasoning tastes good you’re ready to use!
Easy Variations and Swaps

Once you have the formula down for making the perfect Everything Bagel Seasoning you will easily be able to customise it. As it is just a guide, you can easily replace one ingredient for another. Just make sure you only change one thing at a time so you know what has helped or hindered your blend. Here are 3 of the easiest customisations to try!
Low-Sodium Everything Bagel Seasoning
Cut down the amount of salt you’re using. Half the amount you normally use or even none at all whilst adding some dried lemon zest or sumac. Dried garlic and onions will help give lots of flavour. Alternatively, use salt but just add to each portion at the table so you know how much you are having.
Spicy and Savory Twists
To add a bit of spice, mix in 1/2 part red pepper flakes or a pinch of cayenne. A touch of smoked paprika or toasted onion flakes will give a more earthy flavour. Using a little dried dill will give it a fresh, deli style taste perfect for salmon. Start with a little and build up by mixing in more while you taste.
No Poppy Seeds? Use These Swaps
Black sesame seeds are an easy substitute. If you have any chia seeds or nigella seeds then these will do although the nigilla will have a slightly more pungent taste. Dried garlic or onion powder can be substituted if you run out of the flakes. However, use roughly half the amount. Try to use the sesame seeds if you can as they give this mix its distinctive crunch.
Fixing Your Everything Bagel Seasoning Ratio
However, even with the perfect ratio you might still find that your batch doesn’t taste quite right. The most common issue will be that there is too much salt. To fix this don’t throw it away! Simply add more sesame seeds, one spoonful at a time until the saltiness is balanced. The best way to balance the mixture is by adding more seeds. This won’t add any harsh flavours to your mix. You can taste your mix after each addition until it feels balanced.
If your mix is too bland, this is usually because there isn’t enough garlic and onion or your jar has gone off. Simply add a little more of both ingredients and increase the amount of salt slightly. You may also find that the seeds have settled in the jar. Small poppy seeds will sink to the bottom of the jar whilst the larger sesame seeds will float to the top. So give your jar a good shake before using.
Ways to Use Homemade Everything Bagel Seasoning

The most obvious option is bagel and cream cheese. Sprinkle the seasoning mix directly over cream cheese or press a buttered half of bagel into a dish of cream cheese and toast. Avocado toast is another option and so is fried or scrambled eggs. You can even have some plain buttered toast! We recommend using around half a teaspoon per portion but can be added more if desired.
Not just for breakfast! Add it to your roasted vegetables such as Cauliflower or Brussels sprouts in the last few minutes of cooking to avoid burning the garlic. This also goes really well with salmon, chicken and homemade crackers. A tiny pinch can be added to some popcorn or a spoonful mixed through softened butter or Greek yogurt to create an instant dip. As there is salt in the mix, always taste your food first and only add a little to season.
How to Store DIY Everything Bagel Seasoning

You want to keep moisture out so choosing an air tight container to store in. The best way is to use a small glass jar with a tight sealing lid. A spice jar (shaker) is handy to use everyday. Ensure the jar is completely dry. Store your sesame seed in a cool dark place. Don’t store near the stove or dishwasher as the heat and steam can cause clumping and will make them lose their flavour.
For the best taste use within 6 months. As sesame seeds are naturally oily they will become stale over time. If you’ve made a large amount store any spare in the freezer. Label how much you’ve put in with the date. If your sesame seeds smell off or musty throw them away and make a fresh batch.
FAQs About Everything Bagel Seasoning Ratio DIY
What’s the best everything bagel seasoning ratio DIY?
Best to start with 2 portions sesame seeds and 1 portion of poppy seeds, dried minced garlic, dried minced onion, coarse salt. Just use whatever spoon you have to measure your portions. This DIY everything bagel seasoning ratio will work for any quantity you are making. You can also adjust the amount of salt to your taste.
How much salt should I add to homemade everything bagel seasoning?
This recipe requires 1/6 of the total mixture to be salt. To reduce the salt levels you can halve the amount of salt required or simply leave it out and salt your food on the plate. We would suggest using coarse kosher salt or flaky salt as the fine salt will taste saltier.
Can I make everything bagel seasoning without poppy seeds?
Yes. You can easily substitute them with equal amounts of black sesame seeds, nigella seeds or chia seeds. The black sesame seeds will give your cakes the traditional seeded look and taste most like poppy seeds. If you are leaving out the poppy seeds completely then add a little extra sesame seed to keep the mixture crunchy.
How long does DIY everything bagel seasoning last?
For the best taste, use your homemade everything bagel seasoning within 6 months. Store it in an airtight jar somewhere cool and dark, to avoid any heat or steam. The garlic and onions will begin to lose their flavour. If you can smell any staleness or see any dampness on the mix then it is best to bin it and make a new batch.
What can I use everything bagel seasoning on besides bagels?
Use on eggs, avocado toast, roasted vegetables, salmon, chicken, popcorn and homemade crackers. Mix into soft butter, cream cheese or Greek yogurt to make a quick spread or dip. Start using ½ tsp per serving as it contains salt.
Do I need to toast the sesame seeds for homemade everything bagel seasoning?
While not essential, toasting will give them a richer, nuttier taste, and will make them crunchier. If you are using pre-toasted sesame seeds then do not toast them. Allow the seeds to fully cool down before mixing, otherwise the steam could cause them to clump together.
Final Thoughts on Your DIY Everything Bagel Seasoning Ratio
The secret to a good blend is getting the perfect balance! This recipe uses individual elements so once you’ve found the perfect balance for your everything bagel seasoning DIY mix you can easily scale it up or down. You can also change the amount of salt and seeds to suit your taste. This only takes around 5 minutes to make so you won’t have to run out to buy more!
Make a small batch this weekend and try it with some cream cheese on a toasted bagel. Adjust the salt, garlic or heat to suit your taste! If you have a favourite variation then leave me a comment below to let me know what changes you made!