Best Jars for Homemade Spice Blends: What to Buy and What to Skip 

Selecting the right jars to store your DIY spice mixes seems straightforward, but there are some pitfalls. You whip up your fresh taco spice mix on a Sunday afternoon, pour it into any spare jar you have to hand and then you discover a month down the line that it has gone claggy, flavourless or just smelly (like last years garlic powder). Choosing the correct jar is actually very important as it will control how much air, light and moisture your spice mix is exposed to ultimately affecting how tasty your spices will be.

Throughout this guide you will learn how to select the right material, size, lid type, light-proof properties, labelling and best storage conditions for your spice jars. You will also discover what to do with those old store bought jars piling up in your cupboard! At the end of this guide you will know exactly what to buy and what to avoid.

What Makes a Good Jar for Homemade Spice Blends? 

To keep your homemade spice mixes fresh, find a jar that will keep air and light out and last well. While jars with funky designs and trendy labels look nice, they won’t help keep your spice mix fresh. As homemade spice mixes are mainly made up of ground spices, they will lose their flavour quicker than whole spices. Ground spices can also become clumpy if there is any moisture in the jar.

When choosing the best jars for your homemade spice mixes look for jars with a tight fitting lid to keep out the humidity. The lid should also be large enough to fit a spoon or funnel into. If your spice mix is going to be used regularly then ensure that the jar is easy to scoop from. Or if you’re giving them as a gift ensure they look nice!

Glass, Plastic, Metal, or Ceramic: Which Spice Jar Material Wins? 

Your first choice will be what material to use. Glass, plastic, metal and ceramic can all be used to some extent however they will not all be the same. They differ in terms of airtightness, smell, exposure to light and how easy they are to clean. It is best to think about these points before purchasing a full set. Below is how they would hold up when storing a fresh mixture.

Why Glass Spice Jars Are the Best Overall Pick

Glass spice jar with airtight silicone gasket holding a homemade seasoning blend

 Glass is great for home cooks. It won’t pick up any odours or discolour like plastic would. You can easily clean your jars between uses. They are also non reactive so you won’t spoil your salty or citrusy blends. Glass jars with silicone gaskets will provide an excellent seal and you can easily tell when you need more. However they are heavy and can be fragile. You shouldn’t put them on the edge of a busy counter top.

When Plastic Spice Jars Make Sense 

Glass versus plastic spice jars compared side by side for storing homemade blends

A great option, although there are some issues. Plastic is very lightweight, inexpensive and almost indestructible. This makes it great for camping or taking on holiday with your spices. The problem with using plastic is that it can absorb smells and become stained, particularly with turmeric, paprika and chilis. Some lids can also become less airtight over time. If using plastic, look for thick food grade containers and store fast using blends in these.

Tins, Stainless Steel, and Ceramic Options 

Metal tins and stainless steel jars are great for holding ground blends as they are completely light proof. They last a long time and can easily be stacked in a draw. You will not be able to see how much you have left so make sure you label them well. A ceramic crock looks lovely on the counter top but many are not airtight. These would be good for storing salt or small amounts of blend that you will use fast.

Clear, Amber, or Opaque: Protecting Your Blends From Light 

Amber and clear glass jars holding homemade spice blends side by side

Light can be an enemy of your spice blends. If kept in sunlight or bright kitchen conditions you will notice your colours fading and flavours becoming weaker. The most noticeable change will be to your green herbs such as basil and parsley and your red spices such as chillies or paprika. A transparent jar will look nice on a sunny windowsill however the transparency of the jar will affect how much light enters so choosing a specific colour may help.

A amber jar is ideal to help reduce the amount of light entering whilst still allowing you to see how much is getting through. Opaque jars such as those made from stainless steel or ceramics will block all light but you won’t be able to see how much is getting through. Clear glass jars will work well if they are kept inside a cupboard or draw. Either way ensure that they aren’t placed directly in sunlight or near the heat of the stove.

What Size Jars Work Best for Homemade Spice Blends? 

The biggest difference between homemade spice mixes and store bought ones will be the size. Most recipes produce small amounts of mix so we need to choose an appropriately sized jar. Using a large jar will leave more space for air which will cause the flavours to degrade quicker. We simply want a jar that will fill up to near the top. For most kitchens you will want to use either a 50ml, 100ml or 250ml jar. Here is a brief overview of the jar sizes and their opening.

Standard 4-Ounce Spice Jars for Everyday Blends 

The most popular size is the 4 oz. This way you will get a full batch of many of your everyday seasonings, like taco or Italian seasonings. The jars will fit on most spice racks and/or drawer inserts. If you are using a seasoning each week, store one in your cooking drawer and another one in your pantry. This is a great place to start if you’re unsure what to buy.

Mini Jars for Gifts and Small Batches 

Mini and four-ounce spice jar sizes compared for homemade seasoning batches

Mini sized jars (usually between 1-2oz) are perfect for trial recipes and/or crafting gifts. They allow you to experiment with your blends and if you do make your own in a small batch they will fill up your mini jars to the brim leaving little air in the jar. They look lovely in gift sets and can be labelled to match. However, due to their small size they will run out fast!

Wide Mouth vs. Narrow Mouth Openings 

The size of the opening on your jar makes a difference. For filling and scooping your ingredients wide mouth jars are great. They are easy to clean. This would be the best option for rough mixtures such as everything bagel seasoning. Small openings work well with shaker tops, so you can get good control over how much you sprinkle. If you have to choose one go for a wide mouth jar but add in a shaker top if needed.

Lids That Keep Spice Blends Fresh 

Don’t forget your lid! This will affect how much air and moisture gets into the jar each time. Since there are no anti-caking ingredients in homemade mixes, a great jar won’t help if the lid is loose. You will end up with a clumpy and dull seasoning. Think of how you will be using your mix. The best lid for sprinkling may not be the best for storing.

Shaker Tops vs. Solid Lids 

Shaker top and solid airtight lid on glass jars for homemade spice blends

Shakers are great for easy seasoning but they do allow steam and humidity into the seasoning through the holes. A solid lid will keep your seasoning more protected. If you can find a jar that has a shaker section inside with a solid lid this is the best option. You’ll be able to shake your seasoning while cooking but have it sealed for the rest of the time.

Airtight Seals and Silicone Gaskets 

If you are using salt, sugar or dried citrus in your mixtures then it is worth sealing your jars tightly. The silicone gasket will sit tightly around the edge of the jar to stop damp air getting into the jar. To test your jar you can screw the lid on and press down. The lid shouldn’t rattle or pop off. If your gasket becomes hard, cracked or smells bad then you should replace it as it won’t seal properly anymore.

Bamboo and Decorative Lids 

Bamboo and cork lid jars are very popular for gifting. Most lids will not provide an airtight seal so they have a silicone ring inside. Wood can absorb strong odours such as garlic and cumin. If using decorative lids for blends that you will be gifting or using up in the next few weeks then you should have an airtight jar for storing longer.

Best Jars for Homemade Spice Blends by Kitchen Type 

The best jars will depend on the size of your kitchen space. Whether you have a large pantry, small apartment space or a space for gifts, you’ll want different jars. Below you’ll find the best types of jars to use depending on your space (no brand names given so you can go to any store).

Best Overall Spice Jars for Everyday Blends 

Row of glass jars filled with homemade spice blends on a kitchen shelf

Use 4 oz glass jars with silicone gasket lids and wide mouths. They are easy to fill and clean and will seal well. They can also fit into most rack systems and drawer inserts. If you only plan on using one jar size for your blends, this is the one to go for.

Best for Small Kitchens: Magnetic and Stackable Jars 

Vertical jars work well in small kitchens. Magnetic jars attach to the side of your fridge/ metal board to keep your cabinets clear. Square stackable jars are great for tucking into drawers or slim cabinets. Ensure the lids fit tightly on the jars as some space saving jars do sacrifice a good seal for a neat design. Magnetic jars shouldn’t be used near the stove as the heat and steam can affect your blends.

Best for Gifting: Mini Jars With Cork or Screw Lids 

Mini spice jars with twine and tags as gifts of homemade blends

Very stylish and cheap are small jars with either a cork or screw lid. The screw lid is the best option for posting or throwing into a bag as the cork can fall out. Attach a label with the name of the blend, date made and quick hint on how to use it. These are easy, cheap and personal gifts. Just fill up the small jar with twine around it.

How to Label Jars of Homemade Spice Blends 

Using a label will give you peace of mind. When you make your own mixes it can be difficult knowing what each one is because they’ll all appear the same. Using a label means you will know what your chili rub is and what your curry mix is. It also means you can write an expiry date on them unlike shop bought spices. A good label should be easy to read, compact and durable.

What Every Spice Blend Label Should Say 

Labeling a glass jar of homemade spice blend with the blend name and date

Keep it simple. Write the name of the mix and the date you made it. This will help you keep track of its ‘use by’ date. If there are any key ingredients within the mix that you should mention – like chili, mustard or sesame – write those in small text underneath. It is also good to include a quick tip about how to use your mix, for example 1tbsp per lb of chicken. Make sure to write your label on the front of the jar so you can see it when stacking.

Waterproof Labels That Survive Spills 

Paper labels don’t stand up well to being next to all that steam, oil and grubby fingers so go for a waterproof label made of vinyl or polyester. You can then write your labels using a permanent marker pen or print with waterproof ink. Although chalkboard style labels look cute they are easily smudged. If you are going to reuse your jars then try using a reusable label. This will save you having to spend 10 minutes wiping your jar clean so you can change your mix and label.

How to Fill and Store Your Spice Blend Jars 

Funnel filling a glass spice jar with a homemade seasoning blend

Fill the jars as soon as your mix is fully combined and cooled. Any slight heat or dampness can cause the mixture to clump together. Use a small funnel to avoid any spillage around the rim of the jar (this can cause the lid to not seal properly). Leave a quarter inch gap at the top of the jar then gently tap to allow the mix to settle. If you have a spare half jar of mix from the recipe transfer to a smaller jar to reduce air inside.

It is also important to store your jars somewhere cool, dark and away from the stove, dishwasher and sunny windows. This will help prevent the mix losing it’s flavour. Have your frequently used jars in an easily accessible place and back up with some in the pantry. Check your mixes every few months and replace if they lose their colour or scent.

What to Do With Old Spice Jars 

You can reuse most glass jars from the shops. After cleaning thoroughly, soak them in hot soapy water. Remove labels and clean off any sticky residue with a bit of bicarbonate of soda or cooking oil. Rinse and allow to dry completely. Any moisture left behind can cause your new mixture to form clumps.

If strong smells get into your jars (especially garlic, curry, chilli) clean the jar and leave it open to dry out. Alternatively give it a quick rinse with a little white vinegar and water. To sterilise your jars place them in a hot cycle on your dishwasher or boil them for a few minutes in some water. Make sure they are completely dry. Any jars with a chipped edge or a lid that no longer fits tightly should be replaced.

FAQs About the Best Jars for Homemade Spice Blends 

What’s the best jar for homemade spice blends? 

Labeled glass jars of homemade spice blends ready to store

A wide mouth glass jar with silicone gasket (4oz) is ideal for most home cooks. The glass won’t absorb any smells or stains. The gasket will help keep out moist air. The size of jar will reduce excess air in your jar, whilst holding a standard sized batch. If your pantry is well lit, you should choose amber glass jars or store them in an airtight cupboard.

Are glass or plastic spice jars better? 

Glass containers are best for most mixes. They are easy to clean and don’t absorb any odours from the garlic and chilli. They also don’t absorb staining from turmeric or paprika. A plastic container is lightweight and almost indestructible making them ideal for camping or on the go mixes. If using a plastic container choose thick food grade jars to store fast using mixes.

Do amber jars keep spices fresher than clear jars?

Yes, amber jars do help prevent fading by blocking out much of the light. However, how you store your jar is also very important. If you keep your clear jar in a dark and cool cupboard it will be just as good as an amber jar kept on a bright shelf. Opaque jars such as stainless steel tins will block out all light. 

What size jar do I need for one batch of homemade spice blend?

Pick out a jar. A 4oz jar works best for most recipes such as taco or Italian seasoning. If you’re making your batch on a smaller scale or just making it as a gift, go for a mini jar (1-2 oz). The goal is to have your batch fill your jar nearly all the way. More air means faster flavour loss.

How do you keep homemade spice blends from clumping in jars?

Clumps form from moisture. So ensure both your blend and jar are totally dry and cool before adding to jar. Ensure you’re using an airtight lid and don’t shake your spices over a hot pan. Salt, sugar and dried citrus blends will be the most prone to clumping, so store in airtight jars. If any of your blends are still clumping then simply use a fork to break up the clumps and transfer to a smaller jar.

Can I reuse store-bought spice jars for homemade blends? 

Yes but they need to be thoroughly cleaned. Soak, remove labels and stickiness and allow to dry completely. Wash with hot soapy water or a vinegar rinse to eliminate strong odours. Don’t use any jars which have a broken edge or a lid that doesn’t fit tightly as this will not protect your blend.

Final Thoughts on the Best Jars for Homemade Spice Blends 

The best spice jars you can use for making your own spice mixtures are glass jars that are sealed and the correct size. Label them clearly with the date and store somewhere cool and dark so that your spices will last much longer and keep their flavour. You don’t need to go all out with matching jars!

Start off by getting a few 4oz glass jars and making a mixture you tend to use often. Once you have seen how much better they taste and last, you can easily upgrade by getting some mini jars to give as gifts or even a drawer insert. Simply make a batch, pop into the jar, label and enjoy!

Leave a Comment