Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices: Toast, Grind, and Store 

Making homemade garam masala whole spices is the answer to your old, stale jar of masala. When you open your jar you get a faint dusty smell instead of the warm sweet scent you were hoping for. Pre ground mixes don’t last very long and after using half your jar it can have lost its flavour. Whole spices will keep the oils inside them until you grind them.

In this post I will tell you which whole spices are needed and where to find them in the US. I will take you through how to toast, grind and sieve your spices without burning them. I will show you the most common mistakes when grinding. Finally I will explain the difference between garam masala and curry powder and how to store it. Plus I will give you some easy ways to use it and some substitution ideas.

Why Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices Taste Better Than Store-Bought 

Garam masala is a fragrant and warming spice mix used throughout Indian cooking. It tends to be stirred through dishes towards the end of cooking. The scent of garam masala in your dish will therefore become one of the most important spices you’re using due to the fact it’s added so close to the end. By grinding the whole spices you’ll have an incredibly fresh blend that adds lots of depth to your curries and lentils.

Fresh Flavor vs. Dusty Jars 

Once your spice has been ground then the flavourful oils will begin to evaporate. Garam masala that you buy can often be left sitting in the warehouse and on the shelf for a while. Whole spices keep the oils locked in the tough shell. Therefore, using homemade garam masala whole spices will give you a more intense aroma, more rounded flavour and lots more flavour in every spoonful.

What Garam Masala Actually Tastes Like 

Garam masala has a very rich, sweet and spicy taste. The cardamom and cinnamon provide hints of sweetness. There is also a richness in the masala from the cloves. There are a few hints of spiciness and earthy flavours with the black pepper and cumin. This is not hot pepper masala. It does leave you with a warm feeling in the background without any real spicy bite.

What Goes Into Garam Masala From Whole Spices 

There is no official recipe for garam masala as every family and region will have slightly different recipes. However, most recipes use similar types of whole spices to give a sweet, grounding and peppery mix. There are 10 ingredients here which can be found in most US supermarkets or online. Don’t be put off by the number of ingredients, each spice has a role within the blend and once you know what they do everything will make sense!

The Core Spices and What Each One Does 

Whole spices for garam masala, including cardamom, cloves, cumin, and cinnamon, labeled on a wooden board

Coriander and cumin seeds provide an earthy base, whilst black peppercorns bring pepperiness. Fennel seeds offer a mild sweet licorice flavour. Cloves are very pungent with a slight tingling feeling, so only use a little. Green cardamom seeds have a sweet, flowery and citrusy aroma (throw away the husks). Cinnamon sticks, bay leaves and whole nutmeg provide a warm sweet nutty finish.

Optional Add-Ins for More Heat or Sweetness 

Add a dash of whole ground red chillies or red pepper flakes for extra heat. To make it sweeter, add a little more cardamom or cinnamon. Be careful not to add too much extra nutmeg as it can become bitter. Once you have made the base recipe try adding one spice at a time to a new batch. You can note down any changes you make so that you can recreate your favourite blend.

Where to Buy Whole Spices for Garam Masala in the US 

 You won’t have a problem finding coriander, cumin, black peppercorns, clove and cinnamon sticks in most large supermarkets. They will be in the spice aisle. The issue is that they tend to be more expensive per ounce and may not have been used for a long time. Whole nutmeg and green cardamom can be more tricky to find. If your local supermarket only sells ground spices then try looking in the baking section or international section.

The best place to go to get fresh, good value spices is at an Indian or international grocery store. The spices will be sold quickly and will come in bigger sized bags. Often the spices will be cheaper than the ones in the jars. An online store is also a good option. Cardamom and bay leaves can easily be bought online. Look for whole, uniform colours and strong scents. Avoid any that look old and crumbly and choose plump green cardamom pods.

Tools You’ll Need for Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices 

Skillet, spice grinder, sieve, and jar of garam masala on a clean wooden board

You will only need a few pieces of kit. A dry frying pan or heavy pan (cast iron or stainless steel) will do nicely. You’ll need something to grind your spices with. A blade coffee grinder that you only use for spices is a good option. Or alternatively a spice grinder. If you don’t mind the extra effort you could use a mortar and pestle. Whatever you go for make sure it’s completely dry and clean to avoid any taste from leftover coffee or old spice mixing into your blend.

A fine sieve, small bowl and airtight glass jar will be needed. The sieve will help catch any large pieces of cinnamon bark and nutmeg. The jar will help keep your blend fresh. Choose something similar in size to your batch. The less air in the jar the better. A kitchen scales will help if you are trying to make an exact copy of the recipe but measuring spoons will be fine for your first batch.

How to Make Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices Step by Step 

This homemade garam masala can be made in just 15 mins. Simply weigh out your spices, toast in a dry pan, then allow to cool and blitz to make a fine powder. Nothing complicated here, just keep everything organised. If you over-toast your spices you will end up with a bitter taste. And if you blitz when they’re still warm, you’ll end up with clumpy spice. But just follow these steps and you’ll have around half a cup of fresh, fragrant spice.

Prep and Measure the Spices 

Place 3 Tablespoons of coriander seeds, 2 Tablespoons of cumin seeds and 1 tablespoon of black peppercorns in a bowl. Add 1 tablespoon of fennel seeds. Add 1 teaspoon whole cloves and 1 tablespoon green cardamom seeds. If your cardamom pods are intact then crack them open and remove the papery skins, only the little black seeds go into the mixture. Chop 2 cinnamon sticks into small pieces. Tear 2 bay leaves in half. Set the nutmeg aside.

Toast Your Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices the Right Way 

Toasting whole spices in a dry skillet for homemade garam masala

Heat a dry non-stick pan on a medium-low setting. Add the coriander, cumin, fennel, peppercorns and cloves to the pan, and stir continuously for around two minutes. Add the cardamom seeds, cinnamon, bay leaves and any dried chillies. Stir for one minute. When the kitchen is filled with a lovely warm aroma and the cumin has slightly darkened, it is ready. If you smell any harshness or smoke, then remove it from the heat straight away, as burnt spices will be very bitter.

Cool, Grind, and Sift the Blend 

Freshly ground garam masala powder in a jar next to a spice grinder

Place the toasted spices on a plate to cool completely (10 minutes). Ensure they are cooled as hot spices will cause clumping in your grinder. Pulse to grind using two small batches to produce a fine powder. Once you have a fine powder, add approximately half a whole nutmeg grated and combine. To ensure you have a fine powder, place in a fine mesh sieve and sift. Grind any larger particles again.

Common Mistakes When Grinding Garam Masala From Whole Spices 

Most issues with making garam masala come down to small mistakes. The most common issue is cooking on a high heat. This causes the cloves and peppercorns to burn whilst the coriander doesn’t get hot enough. The second issue is using the spices too hot. This will cause the powder to clump together and create a bland result. Cook the spices on a medium low heat and allow them to completely cool for 10 minutes.

The spices can also be an issue. Whole spices such as cinnamon and nutmeg can be tricky. Don’t overload the grinder with large pieces of cinnamon and whole nutmegs. Chop the cinnamon into small pieces and grate the nutmeg. Fill the grinder half way so that the spices will grind evenly. Also make sure the grinder is clean between each batch so any left over coffee or chilli won’t mix in.

Garam Masala vs. Curry Powder 

Two bowls comparing garam masala and curry powder on a wooden board

Garam masala and curry powder are very similar in appearance but have very different uses. Curry powder is usually based around turmeric which makes it golden yellow. It provides a base flavour to your dish. Garam masala does not contain any turmeric and has a warm, sweet and fragrant taste. Curry powders are often added at the beginning of cooking to create a sauce base. Garam masala is usually added towards the end of cooking to keep it fresh.

This will impact the overall taste of your dish. Curry powder will give your dish an earthy savoury taste that will blend into your sauce. Garam masala will give your dish a fragrant taste. A little pinch can really bring a pot of lentils or chicken to life. They can be used interchangeably although your dish will taste different. If you enjoy making your own blends then a homemade curry powder would be a good next project!

How to Store Homemade Garam Masala From Whole Spices 

Labeled glass jar storing homemade garam masala from whole spices

Spices can go bad easily due to heat, light and air. Once cooled pour your mixture into a clean dry jar with a lid. Store this in a cool place inside your kitchen away from the stove top and any bright windows. If you store your jar above your stove top it will lose it’s scent quicker. Label your jar with the date like you would with any homemade spice blends.

Try to use within a few months to get the best flavour out of your spices. Although they won’t go off quickly they can lose their scent. If you feel your spices are losing their scent rub some between your fingers and smell them. If there is little scent and they smell old then it’s time to make another batch. The recipe only takes 15 minutes so it’s better to make smaller amounts.

Easy Ways to Use Your Freshly Ground Garam Masala 

The best way to use Garam Masala is simply to sprinkle into your recipes at the end. Add half a teaspoon to lentils, chickpea curry or chicken stew in the final few minutes of cooking to allow the spices to release their scent. Alternatively you can cook (sauté) them in a little hot oil or ghee for around twenty seconds before adding your vegetables. Just start with a little as you can always add more.

You can use it to season roasted cauliflower or sweet potatoes by tossing with a little before putting into the oven. Simply stir in a little into some plain yoghurt for an instant dip. Or rub onto chicken thighs along with salt and oil. It goes well with rice, soups and even popcorn! Try one new idea each week and see what you like.

Garam Masala Substitutes and the Ground-Spice Shortcut 

If you don’t have any whole spices to hand, you can still make a good substitute using your ground spice cupboard. Simply mix ground coriander, cumin, black pepper, cinnamon, cardamom, cloves and nutmeg together. Use the same proportions as above, but use slightly less of each (the ground spices will pack tighter into a spoon). Don’t toast them, however you can give them a quick 30 second dry fry in a pan to bring out the flavour. They won’t be quite as flavoursome as freshly ground but they will be much better than using an old jar.

If you have absolutely no garam masala, then you can make a quick substitute by mixing equal parts of cumin, cinnamon and black pepper with a very small amount of ground cloves. You can also use mild curry powder. This will have a more earthy taste, and a more yellow colour. Use only about half of the amount, taste and adjust to your liking. Add at the end of cooking to keep the aroma.

FAQs About Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices 

Is garam masala spicy? 

No. Garam masala is warm and spicy with just a hint of heat from the black pepper. Generally, it will be quite sweet and fragrant and won’t give you a burning feeling on your tongue. To give the garam masala more heat simply add a little dried red chilli or red pepper flakes into the pan whilst toasting.

Can I make garam masala with ground spices? 

Yes. Mix some ground coriander, cumin, black pepper, cinnamon, cardamom, cloves and nutmeg together in similar proportions but using a little less of everything. Heat it in a dry pan for 30 seconds. It won’t be quite as punchy but is a good option.

How long do homemade garam masala whole spices stay fresh? 

Use within a few months for best taste. The mixture won’t go off quickly but will lose its fragrance. Store the mixture in an airtight glass jar in a cool dark cupboard. If a small amount has little scent and feels dusty when rubbed between your fingers then make up a fresh batch.

Do I have to toast the spices first? 

No, but you will be missing out. Toasting the spices in a dry skillet will help release their natural oils and give more depth of flavour. They will taste less intense and sometimes slightly bitter if you do not toast them. Even just toasting them for a minute will help if you are short on time, and make sure you let them cool down before grinding.

What’s the difference between garam masala and curry powder? 

Curry powder usually includes turmeric, giving a yellow colour and savoury, earthy base. Garam masala doesn’t include turmeric and has more of a warm and sweet flavour. Curry powder is usually added at the beginning of cooking to create a sauce whereas garam masala is added towards the end of cooking to give a fragrant finish.

What can I use if I’m out of garam masala? 

Combine equal parts ground cumin, cinnamon, and black pepper with a little bit of ground cloves. Alternatively you can use mild curry powder (it will be more earthy) but using about 1/2 the amount of powder. Taste and adjust to your liking. Add at the end of cooking to keep the fragrance fresh.

Final Thoughts on Homemade Garam Masala Whole Spices 

Once you’ve had a whiff of this freshly toasted version it will be hard to go back to your jar. Making your own garam masala whole spices takes a bit more work but gives you a beautifully balanced spice mix that really adds something to simple meals. As long as you toast them low and allow to cool completely and then grind in small batches you will have perfect results.

Try making this yourself this week! Get your whole spices and make a half cup batch. Add a pinch to your meal tonight and let me know how you got on in the comments!

Leave a Comment