DIY Pumpkin Pie Spice Blend With a Secret Ingredient

This homemade pumpkin pie spice mix takes around 5 minutes to make and most of the ingredients will be in your pantry. After mixing your pie filling and getting your oven nice and hot you reach for your jar… only to find it’s empty! This way you can make a fresh batch of warm and bright spice mix to add to your pie. You’ll also know exactly what has gone into your mix.

In this post you’ll learn how simple the ratio is to make this spice mix. I’ll tell you what 5 warm spices to use as a base and the secret ingredient (black pepper) which adds a little kick. You’ll also learn some easy substitutions if you don’t have all the spices, how to use this mix for more than just pies and how to store your mix. By the end of this you’ll never need to buy a jar again!

What Goes Into a DIY Pumpkin Pie Spice Blend

Cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, allspice, and black pepper in small bowls

This homemade pumpkin pie spice recipe uses only six spices! Five of which will be familiar to you, and one will come as a surprise. This combination will give your pie a nice balance of sweet, earthy, slightly sour and gentle warmth. All of these ingredients can easily be found in the baking section of any grocery store. Let’s take a look at the role of each of the spices.

The Five Warm Spices in Every Jar

The main spice here is cinnamon so it will be the most prevalent in the jar. Ginger gives a nice spicy kick and nutmeg provides a gentle sweetness. Cloves can be quite overpowering so take care not to use too much as it can leave your pie tasting quite medicinal. Finally, allspice will complete the mix as it has a hint of cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves. If you get the right balance you won’t have any one spice that is too overpowering.

The Secret Ingredient: Black Pepper

Something that the jar won’t tell you. The addition of just a little pinch of black pepper will add a subtle heat to the sweetness of the spice. You won’t taste the pepper but it will add a richness to the mix. Anyone who has drunk chai will be familiar with this. The pepper is often used alongside the cinnamon and ginger. However, use a little bit so you don’t make it taste too savoury.

Checking Your Spices for Freshness

Before mixing, smell your spices. Over time ground spices can stale. If you have spices that have been sitting at the back of your cabinet for years, they will have lost most of their flavour. Rub a little between your fingers and take a sniff. If they smell rich and sweet then they are fine. If they are lacking in scent or smell musty, replace them. A poor spice will result in a bland mixture regardless of how well balanced your ratios are.

The Easy Pumpkin Pie Spice Ratio

This is very easy. 4 parts cinnamon, 2 parts ginger, 1 part nutmeg, 1/2 part each of allspice and cloves, plus a pinch of black pepper. As you are mixing by volume you can use whatever measuring spoons you like. This will replace pumpkin pie spice in equal measure. The following two mixtures should cover most kitchens.

Small Batch for One Recipe

It won’t take very much. For one pie or one batch of muffins, combine 4 tsp cinnamon, 2 tsp ginger, 1 tsp nutmeg, 1/2 tsp allspice, 1/2 tsp cloves and 1/8 tsp black pepper. This will give you around 8 tsp, which should be enough to use in a few recipes. Mix well to ensure that the cloves are distributed throughout the mixture. Spoon into a small jar.

Big Batch for the Season

If you’re baking throughout the Fall then you’ll want to double up this recipe. Multiply all the ingredients by four. 16 tsp cinnamon (approx 1/3 cup). 8 tsp ginger. 4 tsp nutmeg. 2 tsp each of allspice and cloves. 1/2 tsp black pepper. This will give you plenty of space in your half pint jar. Just give it a good shake up before using for the first time.

How to Mix and Make Your Blend

Stirring ground spices together to make homemade pumpkin pie spice

No specialist equipment is needed here, just a small bowl, whisk (or fork) and measuring spoons. Make sure you level off each spoonful using a knife, so that you know that you are getting an exact amount. A heaped teaspoon of cloves will affect the overall mix. Once everything has gone in the bowl, whisk for around 30 seconds. The mixture should look consistent – a warm brown colour without any pale ginger strands.

Transfer the mix to a clean, dry jar and screw the lid on. Shake well for a few seconds to ensure there are no lumps. Give it a quick sniff. You should get a sweet, warm aroma with a hint of peppery spice at the end. If you can really taste the cloves, add a little extra cinnamon.

Smart Swaps When You’re Missing a Spice

If you’re missing one of the spices in the blend, fear not there will likely be an alternative in your pantry. All you need to do is find something with a similar taste but keep it to a small amount to ensure a balance. You’ll never go wrong by having a little play around. The most common substitutions are:

No Cloves or Allspice

If you run short of cloves, you can just leave them out and increase your nutmeg by a pinch. It won’t be quite as tasty but it will still work well in pie and bread. If you’re missing out on allspice, add an extra 1/4 teaspoon of cinnamon and a pinch of nutmeg. If you are leaving out both cloves and allspice you’ll have a version of a basic cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg mix. This will work well in pancakes and oatmeal.

Pre-Ground vs. Fresh-Grated Nutmeg

Using pre-ground nutmeg is fine, but if you can use freshly grated nutmeg. If you are using your own, reduce the quantity slightly. The more pungent option will be using a whole nutmeg and a fine grater (microplane is best). Grate just before you make the mixture as the aroma will quickly fade. Start with roughly 3/4 of the ground amount and then taste and adjust.

Pumpkin Pie Spice vs. Apple Pie Spice

This is a common mistake that lots of people make. Both of them are in the autumn baking aisle and both use cinnamon. The main difference is that pumpkin pie spice has more ginger and cloves in it. This means that it can stand up to the rich earthy taste of the squash. Apple pie spice generally doesn’t have any cloves in it as apples are sweet and tart and don’t need as much spice.

Can you use them interchangeably? Yes, but if you use your homemade pumpkin pie spice in your apple pie you will get a stronger and spicier flavour. However if you use apple pie spice in your pumpkin pie it will taste a little bland. To help with this just add a little extra ginger. If you are baking a lot of both then it is a good idea to have 2 jars labelled so you don’t accidentally use the wrong one.

Best Ways to Use Your Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice Blend

Pumpkin pie slice and a warm latte dusted with pumpkin pie spice

Obviously Pumpkin Pie, but this mix is super versatile. It makes a great all-seasoning for fall. Start off with just a little bit as this can be intense. Most recipes will require anywhere from 1/2-2 teaspoons depending on how much of your mix you’re adding to your batter/liquid. This is why it’s a staple in my cabinet.

In Baking

Start with something classic. A fresh blend of spices makes pumpkin pie, pumpkin bread and spice cake taste even better. If you’re making cookies, muffins or cinnamon rolls, this will add a richer flavour. Add a teaspoon to your banana bread or apple crisp. Or toss your sweet potato or butternut squash with some oil and a little bit of the spice before roasting. You’ll get a lovely sweet, spiced mixture that will give your vegetables a nice colour on the outside.

In Drinks and Breakfast

Mix 1/4 teaspoon into your hot coffee or steamed milk for an instant pumpkin spice latte. Add sugar to taste. Sprinkle into your oatmeal, yoghurt or French toast for an easy autumn breakfast. Mix into your pancake mix, approximately 1/2 teaspoon per cup of flour. A little dusting over whipped cream or hot chocolate will give it that extra autumn flavour. However, be careful not to add too much to your drinks as they can leave a gritty texture.

How to Store Your DIY Pumpkin Pie Spice Blend

Airtight glass spice jar of homemade pumpkin pie spice with a blank label

Spices can become flavourless due to exposure to light, heat and humidity. So your storage location is almost as important as mixing them up. Store them in a cool, dark cupboard away from the cooker. Never leave the jar on top of the oven or next to the dishwasher as they will quickly become bland due to the steam and heat. If you do this you’ll have a fragrant batch all season long.

Best Jars and Labels

Pick out a small airtight jar. Glass jars that are screw-top are ideal as they have a tight seal. The smaller the jar the less air will be trapped in it leaving less chance of losing any flavour. A dark amber glass jar would be ideal as it will block out any light. If you can’t find one then just use any jar and store it in an airtight cupboard. Make sure you write the name and date on the jar. Simply use a piece of masking tape and a pen to write it on.

How Long It Lasts

It will taste at its best when used within around 6 months of making it. After this time it is still safe to use, but will gradually start to lose its flavour. To help keep track of how old it is, write the date on your label. Then give it a quick sniff before using it, if it doesn’t smell very strong then make a fresh batch. It should only take 5 minutes to make. The older mix can still be used to great effect in bakes with strong flavours like spice cake or gingerbread.

FAQs About DIY Pumpkin Pie Spice Blend

How do you make a DIY pumpkin pie spice blend?

Combine 4 tsp of ground cinnamon, 2 tsp of ground ginger, 1 tsb of ground nutmeg, 1/2 tsp ground allspice, 1/2 tsp ground cloves and 1/8 tsp of ground black pepper. Whisk to combine and stir until evenly combined. Transfer to an airtight jar and set aside. This takes around 5 minutes to make and will give you enough for a few recipes.

What’s the ratio for pumpkin pie spice?

Basic rule of thumb is 4 parts cinnamon to 2 parts ginger to 1 part nutmeg to 1/2 part each of allspice and cloves. A dash of black pepper. Since it just uses parts you can easily make as much or little as you like using whatever spoons or scoops you have.

Does pumpkin pie spice have black pepper?

While most pumpkin pie spice bought from the store will not have any black pepper in them, I like to add a pinch of black pepper. It doesn’t give it a pepper flavor but gives it a nice mild heat to enhance the cinnamon and ginger. I add about 1/8 tsp. per batch to keep the mixture sweet.

Can I use pumpkin pie spice instead of cinnamon?

Yes! But you will get a much stronger and more intense flavor. Use the same amount of pumpkin pie spice as you would cinnamon. Taste it and if you want more add it! It goes great with oatmeal, muffins, and coffee. If you are using cinnamon as the main ingredient, such as in snickerdoodles, it can be overpowering.

How long does homemade pumpkin pie spice last?

Homemade pumpkin pie spice will keep its best flavor for around 6 months if kept sealed in an airtight jar in a cool, dark cupboard. It can be kept for longer than this but the flavor will begin to lose its potency. Write the date you made your mix on the jar and always check the smell before using. If it doesn’t smell very strong then make another batch!

Is pumpkin pie spice the same as pumpkin spice?

Yes! Most of the time, these are interchangeable. They’re both the same thing. There’s no real pumpkin in either of them. Pumpkin pie spice is just what it’s called in the baking aisle and pumpkin spice is what it’s called when they’re using it for flavoring (like pumpkin spice lattes and snacks). They are interchangeable 1:1.

Final Thoughts on DIY Pumpkin Pie Spice Blend

This store bought version will seem like a thing of the past once you’ve made your own. This DIY version simply requires mixing together 5 warm spices with a pinch of black pepper to give extra flavour. You can mix a small batch for one recipe or make a large jar to last you throughout the season. Make sure to use fresh spices (give them a sniff!). Use your measuring spoons and make a jar tonight. Let me know in the comments what will be your first recipe to bake!